[tor-relays] new requirements for Tor Exit relays in effect as of 2018-01-20

[nusenu]

Dear Tor Exit Operator,

I'm sending you this email to inform you that 
on 2018-01-20 the requirements for exit operators changed.

Since that date your exit policy MUST allow exiting to port 80 _and_ 443 
to be eligible for the exit flag.

If your exit policy does not meet these new requirements, 
you lost your exit flag on 2018-01-20 (if you used to have it before that date).

Find below a list of 34 exit relays that are affected by these requirement changes
(consensus data as of 2018-01-19 13:00):

contactInfo: 022F 0FF2 CB04 2342 7178  334F BA3F 9725 266C DD10 (OstwaldRipening) 
contactInfo: 0x49FAB046 Chris Jeane <chris jeane AT gmail dot com> (SpikeNJ) 
contactInfo: 0xB4F409D25BC71927 18NkcxXvFQKo2qyTqa6sQNt6bNEgXAvF9U (anoncat1) 
contactInfo: 0xd3956a77 Your pure Manifestation of Peace (newton) 
contactInfo: 0xFDB8716D Gerald Turner <gturner at unzane.com> - 1FRMLK42AvHNwn2NV3ASrxdMDYd12C1qbs (Unzane) 
contactInfo: 1024R/0FCE8549 Alexander Oelzant <alexander at oelzant.priv.at> (SCggHJTyWbtzDA9YZi) 
contactInfo: 145tXZyQEfdmpYhmbFtYe84kjghB5ymPA4 (NormalCitizen) 
contactInfo: 145tXZyQEfdmpYhmbFtYe84kjghB5ymPA4 (OrdinaryCitizen) 
contactInfo: 145tXZyQEfdmpYhmbFtYe84kjghB5ymPA4 (RegularCitizen) 
contactInfo: <admin AT openbsd DOT se> (che) 
contactInfo: Eran Sandler <eran at sandler.co.il> (tor4thepeople2) 
contactInfo: flo at gmx.it (DannenTor) 
contactInfo: Magnus <magnus at 1337.cf> (Pandora) 
contactInfo: nobody AT example dot com (blent) 
contactInfo: Piotr <unknown at yahoo.com> (icubdw2o2xipsdc) 
contactInfo: replace k with c : kontakt @ zwiebeltoralf . de (zwiebeltoralf) 
contactInfo: replace k with c : kontakt @ zwiebeltoralf . de (zwiebeltoralf2) 
contactInfo: Systems Manager <service at ns.sol.net> (soltor0) 
contactInfo: Thor Exit <thor.exit AT yandex dot com> (ThorExit) 
contactInfo: torinternetzforall at aol.com (jUsTwAnTaFREEsHiRt) 
contactInfo: tor-mngr AT scalaire DOT fr (servicePublic2) 
contactInfo: Tsen <tsenchi.ng AT yandex dot com> (mycontribution) 
contactInfo: TvdW <tor AT tvdw DOT eu> - bitcoin 1NKKoCQwKs67eKBGedMD8wYoAs3Z4mMAex (EmpokNor) 
contactInfo: TvdW <tor AT tvdw DOT eu> - bitcoin 1NKKoCQwKs67eKBGedMD8wYoAs3Z4mMAex (TerokNor) 
contactInfo: VolkerWilcken at web dot de (EXITNODESAVE) 
contactInfo: yv3r3nd5yi1k at mail.ru (relay651054) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (alsaceonion) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (alsaceonionb) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (mandela) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (mandelab) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (montrealonion) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (montrealonionb) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (quebeconion) 
contactInfo: <zwiebeln at online de> please donate BTC 1K38x9xqK3YDzjehYFAEPzsESEC4ScH5wJ (quebeconionb)


@niftybunny: I you are motivated, you can send them an email directly by extracting valid email data from this list.

zwiebeln at online de, zwiebeltoralf and TvdW are aware, I don't know about the rest, 
and I obviously omitted those for which we do not have any contactInfo.


The actual learning here are:
Missing proper per-notifications for exit operators. 
This topic (new req: 80+443) has been discussed before [1] but has not been properly announced,
this could have been a TPO tweet or a blog post or an email to this list with proper subject and not hidden in a long thread.
I should auto-detect such events (multiple relays loosing flags at the same time) without knowing about them.

[1]
https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/2017-December/013663.html
https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/2018-January/014278.html
-- 
https://mastodon.social/@nusenu
twitter: @nusenu_

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: signature.asc
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 833 bytes
Desc: OpenPGP digital signature
URL: <http://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/attachments/20180211/038ccd61/attachment.sig>