[tor-relays] More consensus weight problems

[Tom Ritter]

I looked at https://atlas.torproject.org/#details/D60B02A13F5D9CAFD6EC27A5332C5FEF5B769105
/ 4FreeSpeech for the latest vote:

moria:  w Bandwidth=3012 Measured=1890
maatuska: w Bandwidth=3012 Measured=3820
gabelmoo: w Bandwidth=3012
longclaw: w Bandwidth=3012

consensus: w Bandwidth=20 Unmeasured=1

Once you get 3 measurements you should pop over to a real measurement.
(How sane it stays is a whole other issue.)

It's possible (although not simplified) to grab historical
measurements from archived votes and consensuses and figure out how
and when different dirauths voted on you.

-tom

On 12 June 2015 at 12:56, Speak Freely <when2plus2is5 at riseup.net> wrote:
> Zero progress on this, so I thought I'd pop it up again.
>
> I'm only pointing this out because it's interesting, not because I think
> anyone will do anything about it. It may be interesting to someone
> looking into the diversity of consensus weights given a small subset
> from two providers, that is all.
>
> Neither of the two problem relays have gotten rid of their consensus
> weight of 20. One of my other relays has lost significant consensus,
> from 11170 to 1720, its now pushing peanuts, or about 1/10 of what it
> used to.
>
> My oldest relay pushed(in/out) ~10TB last month before losing it's
> consensus weight.
> My other relay, brand new, has been up for about a week and still stuck
> at 20.
>
> All 5 relays come from 2 providers in the euro-region, my other relays
> are not important so are not displayed.
>
> About ~4 hours ago I restarted the 5 relays to see the fun. Since that
> time, here is that status of each:
>
> 1) Measured speed 165.6Kb/s (arm)
>    Downloaded 50.0GB
>    Uploaded   51.0GB
>    Avg Rate:  66.8Mbit/s (vnstat)
>    Consensus  21200
>    Provider   #1
>
> 2) Measured speed 105.4Kb/s (arm)
>    Downloaded 28.7GB
>    Uploaded   29.4GB
>    Consensus  13500
>    Avg Rate   38.13Mbit/s (vnstat)
>    Provider   #2
>
> 3) Measured speed 13.4Kb/s (arm)
>    Downloaded 4.1GB
>    Uploaded   4.3GB
>    Consensus  1720
>    Avg Rate   5.4Mbit/s (vnstat)
>    Provider   #2
>
> 4) Measured speed 160b/s (arm)
>    Downloaded 3.1GB
>    Uploaded   3.2GB
>    Consensus  20
>    Avg Rate   3.82Mbit/s (vnstat)
>    Provider   #2
>    **Oldest relay in list
>
> 5) Measured speed 160b/s (arm)
>    Downloaded 217MB
>    Uploaded   216MB
>    Consensus  20
>    Avg Rate   204kbit/s (vnstat)
>    Provider   #1
>    **Newest relay in list
>
> Relay #5 should be acting more like relay #1. Keep in mind though relay
> #1 was rate limited last week by half because my provider asked me to -
> it was for a period of time happily doing 75-90Mb/s each way. Relays
> #2-4 should all be similar, but they're everywhere.
>
> Enjoy.
>
>
> Matt
> Speak Freely
> _______________________________________________
> tor-relays mailing list
> tor-relays at lists.torproject.org
> https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays