[tor-dev] onionoo: bug in family set detection?

[nusenu]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512

Hi,

by comparing different methodologies of "parsing" myfamily data I
stumbled upon differences between onionoo and compass.

After manual review I assume there is a bug in onionoo (or onionoo has
a different opinion on what families actually are)

Example:

According to onionoo, torpidsDEevanzo [1] is part of a family with 38
members.

It lists torpidsFRonline [2] as one of its members, that implies that
torpidsFRonline lists torpidsDEevanzo as one of its members as well,
but torpidsDEevanzo does _not_ list torpidsFRonline (according to
onionoo data).

grep 'fingerprint":"0C77421C890D16B6D201283A2' details.json|grep
5510FC1736B16D46D3F2DDA5011995C478D42594
(no result)

Is this a bug?

thanks



[1]
https://atlas.torproject.org/#details/5510FC1736B16D46D3F2DDA5011995C478D42594

[2]
https://atlas.torproject.org/#details/0C77421C890D16B6D201283A2244F43DF5BC89DD
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=D6Qh
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----