[tbb-bugs] #14707 [Tor Browser]: Maintain a checklist of symptoms caused by cookie transmission failure

[Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki]

#14707: Maintain a checklist of symptoms caused by cookie transmission failure
-----------------------------+----------------------------------
     Reporter:  michael      |      Owner:  tbb-team
         Type:  task         |     Status:  new
     Priority:  normal       |  Milestone:
    Component:  Tor Browser  |    Version:
   Resolution:               |   Keywords:  TorBrowserTeam201506
Actual Points:               |  Parent ID:  #3246
       Points:               |
-----------------------------+----------------------------------
Description changed by michael:

Old description:

> The Tor Browser blocks 3rd party cookie transmission to provide tracking
> protection. Failure to transmit cookies causes web application errors,
> the reported symptoms of which are documented here. These symptoms are
> relevant when considering other #3246 child tickets such as #14057,
> #14059, and #14085.
> ----
> = Symptoms of cookie transmission failure =
> == Federated logon ==
> VMWare community forums #7279
> Kindle cloud reader (read.amazon.com) #7289
> Autosport.com #9216
> Powdertoy.co.uk #10586
> Bouyguestelecom.fr #11293
> Unseen.is #11294
> LycosMail #11295
> Linkedin.com (JavaScript?) #10631
> == Comment providers ==
> Blogger.com #6427
> Facebook.com (Huffingtonpost)
> Livefyre.com
> Disqus.com (Solved?)
> Google?
> Twitter?
> == Conditional features ==
> Youtube.com (HTML5 video) #3347
> Dailymotion.com (HTML5 video)
> == Approval and rating ==
> Facebook.com (Like)
> Google.com +1 (?)
> == Shopping carts ==
> == Travel reservation ==
> Hotel Valencia Center #14246
> Booking.com (?)
> Travelocity (?)
> Priceline (?)
> Expedia (?)
> Orbitz (?)
> Opodo (?)
> Kayak (?)
> == News and media ==
> Topix.com #7585
> == Survey systems ==
> Surveymonkey.com (?)
> == Document management ==
> Google Drive/Docs #14089
> Box.com (?)
> Dropbox.com (?)
> [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_file_hosting_services
> #File_hosting_services_with_file-sharing_possibility Other popular
> services] (?)
> == Journalist drop services ==
> Strongbox based (?)
> DeadDrop based (?)
> SecureDrop based (?)
> ----
> '''Note:''' This is the product of reports from
> [https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/3246#comment:12 various]
> [https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=565965#c5 reports] and
> [https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/query?keywords=~tbb-usability-
> website&status=!closed usability test] triage.

New description:

 The Tor Browser blocks 3rd party cookie transmission to provide tracking
 protection. Failure to transmit cookies causes web application errors, the
 reported symptoms of which are documented here. These symptoms are
 relevant when considering other #3246 child tickets such as #14057,
 #14059, and #14085.
 ----
 = Symptoms of cookie transmission failure =
 == Federated logon ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||= Trac =||
 ||VMWare community forums||Yes||#7279||
 ||Kindle cloud reader||Yes||#7289||
 ||Autosport.com||Yes||#9216||
 ||Powdertoy.co.uk||Yes||#10586||
 ||Bouyguestelecom.fr||Yes||#11293||
 ||Unseen.is||Yes||#11294||
 ||LycosMail||Yes||#11295||
 ||Linkedin.com||No||#10631||
 == Comment providers ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||= Trac =||
 ||Blogger.com||Yes||#6427||
 ||Facebook.com||Huffingtonpost||||
 ||Disqus.com||API versions?||||
 ||Livefyre.com||Yes||||
 ||Google||No||||
 ||Twitter||No||||
 == Conditional features ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||= Trac =||
 ||Youtube||HTML5 video||#3347||
 ||Dailymotion||HTML5 video||||
 == Approval and rating ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Technology =||= Confirmed =||
 ||Facebook.com||Like||Yes||
 ||Google.com||+1||No||
 == Shopping carts ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||= Trac =||
 ||TBA||TBA||TBA||
 ||TBA||TBA||TBA||
 == Travel reservation ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||= Trac =||
 ||Hotel Valencia Center||Yes||#14246||
 ||Booking.com||No||||
 ||Travelocity||No||||
 ||Priceline||No||||
 ||Expedia||No||||
 ||Trivago||No||||
 ||Orbitz||No||||
 ||Hrs.de||No||||
 ||Opodo||No||||
 ||Kayak||No||||
 == News and media ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||= Trac =||
 ||Topix.com||Yes||#7585||
 == Survey systems ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||
 ||Surveymonkey.com||No||
 == Document management ==
 ||= Hoster =||= Confirmed =||= Trac =||
 ||Google||Drive/Docs||#14089||
 ||Dropbox||No||||
 ||Box.com||No||||
 ||||||[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_file_hosting_services
 #File_hosting_services_with_file-sharing_possibility Other popular
 document services]||
 == Journalist drop services ==
 ||= Technology =||= Confirmed =||
 ||Strongbox||No||
 ||DeadDrop||No||
 ||SecureDrop||No||
 ----
 '''Note:''' This is the product of reports from
 [https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/3246#comment:12 various]
 [https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=565965#c5 reports] and
 [https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/query?keywords=~tbb-usability-
 website&status=!closed usability test] triage.

--

--
Ticket URL: <https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/14707#comment:1>
Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki <https://trac.torproject.org/>
The Tor Project: anonymity online